The History of Huntsville Lodge No. 364 actually begins with the formation of an earlier Lodge in Huntsville, Odeon Lodge No. 44. The demise and short history of this Lodge will result in the formation of Huntsville Lodge No. 364 in 1878.

      Five years after the formation of the Most Worshipful Grand Lodge of Arkansas in 1846, the first Lodge in Madison County—Odeon Lodge No. 44 was chartered on November 6, 1851, having been dispensated earlier that year. The name “Odeon” comes from the Greek and refers to any public hall to be used for entertainment, particularly musical or dramatic presentations. It is not known where the Lodge originally met for the first two years but may have met in the barn of Evan S. Polk or John Sanders, both barns seeming to be meeting places in the early history of Huntsville.  A substantial 2-story building was erected sometime between July 1853 and December 1854 on the NW corner modern day Main and Hughes Streets. The land was purchased from Evan S. and Jane Polk on July 11, 1853.  (The first court ever held in Madison County was in the barn of Evan S. Polk).  The Lodge was to meet in the upstairs and a newly formed college was to meet in the downstairs.

      During the Grand Lodge session of 1851, Mr. John Berry (also a state senator)  of Huntsville was sent as the delegate from the newly dispensated Lodge in Huntsville. During that Grand Lodge session, the Lodge would receive its charter.  Charter members of Odeon Lodge No. 44 were: W. E. Smith, Worshipful Master; James. G. McConnell, Senior Warden; George W. Forest, Junior Warden; Samuel. E. Kenner, Secretary; Members were: J. F. Seaman, O. S. Sanders, J. Youngblood;  John. S. Polk (Blacksmith), Hiram Christian, John Berry, H.C. Berry, A. B. Champlain, J. A. Meek, J. M. Jones, J. Dunlap, A. L. Baker, J. M. Berry, Elias Herrald (Judge), M. Holoford, B. H. Berry, E. Brown, John Vaughn, Vandever Ivie, and M. Owens.

 

      During that same Grand Lodge session of 1851, much discussion was had at that session concerning plans for the establishment of a College in Arkansas to be sponsored by the Masonic fraternity.  As there were no higher institutions of learning in Arkansas, the idea was one of the mains topics at not only that session but at sessions to come.  No doubt delegate John Berry reported this idea to the members of Odeon Lodge and the idea of creating a college in Huntsville that would be more accessible to the northwest Arkansas area would be discussed for the next several years as the Lodge grew.

Home of Odeon Lodge No. 44, The Huntsville Masonic Institute, and later the Huntsville Methodist Church and Huntsville Lodge No. 364.

From the painting—”The Lodge Room over Simpkin’s Store”  - This is typical of what an early country Lodge, such as Odeon Lodge No. 44 might have looked like.

      The year that followed its chartering was indeed a banner year for Odeon Lodge No. 44.  Samuel E. Kenner was elected Worshipful Master, James G. McConnell, Senior Warden, George W. Forest, Junior Warden and Hugh C. Berry, Secretary. The Lodge met on the last Friday of the month and during 1852, the Lodge initiated 14 members in the Entered Apprentice degree, 15 in the Fellow Craft degree and conferred the Master’s Degree on 25 members.  All totaled, the Lodge conferred 54 degrees in 1852, more than any other Lodge in the state.  The rapid growth of the Masonic fraternity is not only evident by this large number of men joining but also by the fact that 17 more new Lodges were created that year in Arkansas bringing the total number to 61.

Another view of a typical Lodge meeting room from the mid to late 1800’s

      It appears that 1853 was another busy year for Odeon Lodge No. 44.  James G. McConnell was elected Worshipful Master, Hugh C. Berry, Senior Warden, John Vaughn, Junior Warden and J. R. Berry was elected Secretary.  The Lodge started the year with 38 members and during the year, 22 were initiated as Entered Apprentices, 23 passed to the degree of Fellow Craft and 22 were raised to the sublime degree of master mason. The records show that 5 members asked to demit from the Lodge that year. This raised the total membership to 55 members. It was during this year that the Lodge decided to build two institutions of higher learning in Huntsville.  The Grand Lodge of Arkansas was readying plans for St. John’s College in Little Rock and Huntsville masons were readying plans for The Huntsville Masonic Institute and the Pleasant View Female Seminary.

      Between 1855 and 1868, Odeon Lodge continued to grow and prosper with membership reaching as high as 107 members. (Huntsville’s population was estimated by union soldiers in 1863 to be just a little over 200). Life and tempers on the frontier being somewhat unpredictable and  sometimes volatile, on June 24, 1859, Forrester Black, a prominent Huntsville attorney and Warren Sams, both members of the Lodge, became involved in an altercation during the celebration of the festival of St. John the Baptist.  Warren Sams drew his knife and Forrester advanced, drew a weapon and fired several shots at Sams killing him instantly. 

 

      As the crowd surrounded the dead man and the reality of what had just happened began to set in, no one noticed that Warren Sams’ young 14 year old son was approaching Forrester from behind.  The young Sams discharged both barrels of his shotgun into the back of the head of Forrester who died shortly.  It is not known what happened to the young Sams but this event is said to have caused quite a sensation in legal and Masonic circles for quite some time.  (From Goodspeeds History of NW Arkansas, p. 451)

 

      One has to wonder why Masons of that era would have so many weapons at a public Masonic gathering in violation of Masonic practices. Although it is not entirely clear what happened, another catastrophe of sorts hit the Lodge in 1869.  It appears that three of the founding members who were also past masters of the Lodge as well as upstanding citizens in the community, were tried before the Lodge.  Presumably, the charges centered around the events of what is now known as the “Huntsville Massacre” (see complete article and Power Point presentation by selecting Huntsville Massacre from the Main Menu) although this cannot be fully substantiated.  The three members, Samuel Kenner, J. S. Polk, and John Vaughn were found guilty of un-Masonic conduct and were expelled from membership. To compound matters, the proceedings of the Most Worshipful Grand Lodge of Arkansas indicate that the trial by the Lodge may not have been proper and the charges leveled by the officers against the men inappropriate.  For whatever reason, the resulting trial and expulsion of the three members destroyed the fellowship and brotherhood of the Lodge. 

 

  During the next five years, the Lodge only existed and rarely met. Finally, in 1875, the Grand Master ordered his District Deputy Grand Master, R. C Armstrong of Bentonville, to go to Huntsville and arrest the charter.  Thus ended the 24 year existence of Odeon Lodge No. 44. and with its departure, both schools under its control ceased operation and forever closed their doors. One has to wonder what Huntsville and Madison County would be like today had these colleges continued and prospered.

      Two years had gone by since Odeon Lodge No. 44 had surrendered its charter and Masonry in the Huntsville area was virtually non existent. Apparently time had healed the wounds of most of the Lodge members as James Gilliland, Charley K. Polk, John Proctor and 22 others including W. A. Gage, J. E. Plummer, P. W. Newton, F. M. Sams, G. T. Berry, C. B. Sanders, John Bowen, William Stotts, and Neal Dorsey, asked the committee on dispensations to grant the Huntsville masons another charter, which the Grand Master granted. 

 

      One would have expected the brothers to ask that the charter of Odeon Lodge be restored, thus allowing the Lodge to keep it’s old name and number. However, this was not the case.  The members decided  it was best not to take up their old name and number and start with an entirely new name and Lodge number.  On October 14, 1878, Huntsville Lodge No. 364 was officially chartered and by 1880 had increased its membership to 38.

 

1879  -  1958

 

  James Gilliland  ‘79 - ‘80

  Charley K. Polk  ‘81 - ‘82

  John Proctor  ‘83 

  William A. Gage  ‘84

  P.W. Newton  ‘85

  John Bowen ‘86

  C.B. Sanders ‘87

  M.F. Knight  ‘88

  J.R. Berry  ‘89

  J.E. Plummer  ‘90

  William A. Gage  ‘91

  W.C. Roberts  ‘92 - ‘93

  F. M. Coger  ‘95

  H.A. Reynolds  ‘96

  J.H. Guinn  ‘98

  Elmer Polk  ‘99

  Z.T. Reynolds  ‘00

  W.T. Brooks ‘01

  W.G. Cannaday  ‘02 - 03, 19

  J.P. Hamilton  ‘05

  Neal Dorsey  ‘07

  Fred Youngblood  ‘08 - ‘09

  John L. Phillips ‘13

  C.L. Fritts ‘15

  Alfred Hawn ‘16 , ‘20

  J.H. Guinn ‘21

  J.F. Moore ‘22, 25

  Omer Basham ’26  -  30, 39,41

  John Gaskill  ‘31 -’32, ‘43 - ‘44

  Loy Hawn  ‘33, ‘40

  Wade B. Anderson ‘34, 36 - ‘38

  Herman Richerson  ‘35

  Harold P. Teague  ‘45

  Ellis Garrison  ‘46